Hal Ashby's films of the 1970s are considered some of the best and most important of their era, yet for so long he was a director who was relatively unknown and unacknowledged.
When I started working on my biography Being Hal Ashby: Life of a Hollywood Rebel, Ashby appeared to be the forgotten man of the New Hollywood generation. "I know that name . . . " people would often say when I mentioned I was working on a book about him. And then, "Remind me, what films did he direct?" But when I listed his movies, people's eyes lit up: Harold and Maude and Being There are probably the most recognizable and beloved, but Shampoo and Coming Home are also popular favorites. The Last Detail and Bound for Glory are well-loved too, and true cinephiles will talk excitedly about The Landlord, Ashby's criminally underseen debut. In fact, Hal Ashby's films of the 1970s are considered some of the best and most important of their era, yet for so long he was a director who was relatively unknown and unacknowledged.
The question that naturally arises is "Why?" While there's no one explanation, a number of significant factors have led to Ashby being consigned to relative obscurity after his death.
During the New Hollywood era, the director was king and auteurs with outsized personalities and ballooning egos thrived: Coppola, Bogdanovich, Friedkin, Scorsese and Altman, not to mention the inventors of the blockbuster, Spielberg and Lucas. As the old Hollywood collapsed and a fresh one replaced it, a film's director became just as important as its stars had once been. In the midst of this group of self-promoting, hyperconfident directors was Hal Ashby, a man who, for all his self-assurance and talent, left his ego at the door and put the work first.
The universal story you will hear from people who worked with Ashby is that he was the most democratic of directors, who would just as readily listen to an idea from a grip as a suggestion from his cinematographer, writer, or lead actor. When Ashby worked on The Big Country (1958) as an assistant editor, that film's director, William Wyler, had told him, "Whenever you have any ideas about anything, please get them out some way." A hippie before the word was invented, Ashby believed in the collaborative nature of filmmaking and took Wyler's philosophy to heart, applying it later in his own work as a director. This was particularly true with actors, who thrived under Ashby's direction -or lack of. Ashby extended great freedom to his actors; he never tried to alter or influence their performance, but instead made it clear that he had complete faith in their abilities. The performances in Ashby's movies were, as a result, vital, genuine, and immediate, and his films from the 1970s received eleven Academy Award nominations for acting. Ironically, this had the effect of taking the focus away from Ashby's contribution to the film.
While beloved by his actors and crew, Ashby drew little attention from the film press; his first few films weren't very successful, and when he had box office hits - with such films as Shampoo, Coming Home, and Being There - the credit was often ascribed to the stars of those movies. What's more, Ashby was not making movies that could be easily lumped together - what, for example, was the connective tissue between the political focus and documentary-like realism of Coming Home and the hippie philosophizing and quaint absurdism of Harold and Maude? - and accordingly, unlike many of his peers, he wasn't seen as an auteur. Andrew Sarris, the American critic who was the major proponent of the auteur theory in the U.S., declared in 1976, "Ashby interests me, but I have not completely figured out his style."2
But perhaps the most important factor in the decline of the public's perception of Ashby was the string of critical and box office failures that defined his post-1970s directing career. The '80s were a dismal decade for him: there were rumours about his drug use and its detrimental effect on his work, and conflicts with studios lead to flop after flop, from the rightfully neglected Second-hand Hearts to the forgotten Neil Simon project The Slugger's Wife, from the uninspired Rolling Stones doc Let's Spend the Night Together to the Jeff Bridges thriller Eight Million Ways to Die, a film that was taken away from him even before he'd started editing it.
Ashby died on December 27, 1988, after a short, difficult battle with pancreatic cancer. His memorial at the Directors Guild of America building was well attended by Hollywood's great and good, but the few obituaries written on him were short and typically focused on the contributions of his collaborators when explaining the success of so many of his films. The picture they painted was of a force long spent, an overrated talent whose favor had run out, and who was now ready to be forgotten.
During the time I was researching and writing Being Hal Ashby, however, there was a noticeable shift. His collaborators and contemporaries had always spoken highly of him, but now the generation of filmmakers who had grown up watching his movies joined them. Watching Hal, Amy Scott's new documentary on Ashby (full disclosure: I am in the film, and also an associate producer), you see one great director after another expressing their deep affection for his work, from Adam McKay, Judd Apatow and Lisa Cholodenko to Alexander Payne, Allison Anders and David O. Russell. Hal premiered to great fanfare at Sundance earlier this year, and the fact that it exists - and debuted on such a big stage - demonstrates that Ashby is finally starting to get his due.
Since Being Hal Ashby was published, four more books on Ashby or his movies have followed, along with releases of Ashby's cut of Lookin' to Get Out andCriterion discs of Being There,Harold and Maude and Shampoo. And this resurgence is no coincidence. Ashby's films perfectly capture the spirit and ideas of the time in which they were made, but they also speak to us today and have qualities that are notably absent from contemporary studio movies.In a time when Hollywood is more focused on car chases and explosions than character and exposition, Ashby's movies provide a much-needed counterpoint. They are stories about people, told with humanity and humor. They tackle big subjects with a light touch. They are edgy and subversive. They have great scripts, memorable performances, subtle directing. They were made within the system, but reflect an outsider's view. For movie lovers today, Hal Ashby's films show us what Hollywood cinema once was and, we hope, will be again.
Nick Dawson
Portions of the above essay previously appeared in the Introduction to Hal Ashby: Interviews, published by the University Press of Mississippi in 2010.